Butterscotch Apple Pie Cookies ~ Creative Cookie Exchange APPLES

Butterscotch apple pie cookies bring the taste of apple pie to a homemade cookie recipe! Fresh apples are the star of this easy dessert recipe.

Butterscotch apple pie cookies bring the taste of apple pie to a homemade cookie recipe! Fresh apples are the star of this easy dessert recipe.

My friend Laura, from The Spiced Life and I, created this awesome monthly event, because, well, who doesn’t love cookies? Breakfast cookies, snack cookies, back to school cookies, Christmas cookies, you name it! If it can be served as a cookie, I’m there!

So, each month Laura and I will decide upon a different theme or ingredient, and then, along with some awesome blogger friends, bake up a big batch of cookies adhering to that theme or ingredient. You can join in by baking some cookies that qualify after we announce our theme every month, and then link up using our linky tool, which will be available at all of the participating bloggers’ sites, including this one.

You can also just use us as a great resource for cookie recipes. Be sure to check out our Facebook page, our Pinterest Board, and our monthly posts. You will be able to find them the first Tuesday after the 15th of each month! 

The Creative Cookie Exchange October 15 – November 18 2013 


 Creative Cookie Exchange

My offering for this round of the #CreativeCookieExchange

Butterscotch Apple Pie Cookies.

Made with just 5 (five) ingredients, I love the simplicity of this apple pie cookies recipe! Butterscotch topping drizzled over the cookies brings perfect balance of sweet and salty; the lattice top-crust give the impression that you spent all day in the kitchen baking! These charming little fruit pies are as lovely to look at, as they are to eat.

Recipe adapted from raininghotcoupons.com and Oh, Bite it

apple pie cookies with butterscotch


Butterscotch Apple Pie Cookies
Yields 12
Luscious and easy to make, fruit pies!
Write a review
Prep Time
15 min
Prep Time
15 min
  1. 1 package pre-made box pie crusts (Pillsbury)
  2. 1 14 ounce can apple pie filling
  3. 3 tablespoons butterscotch topping
  4. 1 egg
  5. 3 tablespoons granulated sugar
  6. 2 teaspoon ground cinnamon
  7. 1 teaspoon butter
  1. Pre-heat oven to 350 degrees
  2. Butter a cookie sheet and mix cinnamon with sugar in a small bowl, set aside
  3. Let pie crust rest at room temperature for 5 minutes, remove pie crust from package and place on a lightly floured surface, using a rolling pin, roll crust slightly for a larger surface
  4. Spread a thin layer of butterscotch over the pie crust
  5. Chop pie filling into very small dice, using 3/4 of a can, spread over crust evenly
  6. Place the other pie crust on a lightly floured surface, roll out slightly as you did with the other crust
  7. cut thin strips to make lattice, about 1/4 inch thick
  8. Start making the lattice by placing strips over the crust with apples, overlapping the strips in a over-under pattern
  9. Beat egg in a small bowl, dip a biscuit or round cookie cutter in egg wash
  10. Using a spatula place cookies on a cookie sheet
  11. Brush lattice with egg wash and sprinkle with cinnamon sugar
  12. Bake for 18-20 minutes until golden brown
  13. Drizzle butterscotch over cookie prior to serving
  1. This is a messy cookie to make but well worth the effort. After you cut the cookie rounds you will have leftover crust and filling, I used the remainder of apple pie filling, to make tucked ramekin apple pies. Add the remaining pie filling evenly to 2 small buttered ramekins, cover with leftover crust and filling, bake for 18 minutes. This is a nice way to salvage the yummy leftover bits
Adapted from Oh, Bite it, Raining Hot Coupons, Pillsbury
At Home with Rebecka http://athomewithrebecka.com/
Butterscotch Apple Pie Cookies - the best fall cookie recipe!

NOTES: On my first run making the butterscotch apple pie cookies, I cut my lattice strips too thick. Next time, I will cut the lattice 1/4 inch thick, creating a tighter weave and a prettier cookie.

making butterscotch apple pie cookies

lattice top to butterscotch apple pie cookies


Butterscotch apple pie cookies bring the taste of apple pie to a homemade cookie recipe! Fresh apples are the star of this easy dessert recipe.

You can participate in our Link Party by baking us a cookie with apples–and keep in mind you may use ANY ingredients made from apples. Raw apples, dried apples, apple jelly, apple brandy, etc… 

Please follow the steps below for the Linky Party: 

1. Write a blog post with recipe and original photo

We would like the recipe to be one you’re making for the first time

Creative Cookie Exchange

3. Make a good faith effort to visit and comment on the other cookies in the Linky Party. We all love cookie so that should be easy

4. Follow my blog At Home with Rebecka

5. Follow me on Twitter @athomewrebecka

6. Follow me on Twitter @thespicedlife

7. LIKE my Facebook Page At Home with Rebecka

8. LIKE The Creative Cookie Exchange 

9. LINK your blog post below

A link will be included below the list that will allow you to get the code for this list and put it on your blog. By doing this, the same list appears on every blog that includes the code so that people can “hop” from blog to blog. As other link up, their recipes will appear on your posts linky.

Please take a moment to visit all the Hosts in this months exchange.

I can’t wait to see your delicious APPLE cookie recipes! Thanks for joining the Creative Cookie Exchange!

Apple Pie Cookie




Welcome to At Home with Rebecka and thank you for taking the time to comment. I love to hear from you. Please identify yourself if you login under Anonymous so I know how to address you.

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

  1. Ahh, pie and cookies. Best combination. I was also going to do Apple Pie cookies this month but I ran out of time for the Cookie Exchange. I definitely will still have to make them though! 🙂 These look so tasty!

    • Sophie, I’ve just purchased all the ingredients to make them again. My family loves them, can’t keep their fingers off them. I’m going to adjust my lattice so it’s tighter, I think they’ll look prettier that way!

    • You’re so welcome ninjabaker! Baking is not my forte so being a part of this group has pushed out of my comfort zone (entrees, appetizers main dish meals). I’ve been having a lot of fun! Thanks for sharing your delicious cookie recipes!!

  2. I was in love with these from when you posted your sneak peek on in our Facebook group, Rebecka. Gorgeous little individual pies that eat like a cookie!

    • Becca, I totally understand! I don’t classify myself as a “real” baker but I love making pies, just ashamed to say that I generally use pre made pie crust! The good news is that these little gems were so easy to make and they were a hit with my family. I know they would dress up any holiday table!

  3. WOW Rebecka those look absolutely over the top delish! Wish I could grab one right through the computer. You’ve got a winner there!